In October of 2016 the organizers of the World OutGames promised an $11 million event with 15,000 registrants.
It didn’t even come close.
On opening they had collected about $1.4 million in revenues while only 2,100 people had registered – forcing organizers to cancel most of the events.
It was a disaster.
The City of Miami Beach conducted a financial audit of the games to determine what went wrong. Mostly it showed there was a lack oversight, while city officials put too much faith in organizers.
For instance, in March, organizers revised their estimates with a new budget of $2.36 million – a mere 20 percent of what they planned for six months prior. They ended up collecting about $1.4 million, half of what they hoped for in March. The audit showed that almost all that money had been spent, leaving $7,000 left in their bank account.
The audit focused on the numbers so it doesn’t show how organizers could have realistically believed they would able to meet that $11 million budget while getting 12,000 more people to register in the last eight months leading up to the games.
The audit given to city commissioners last week showed a lack of oversight and shoddy accounting. It also showed organizers spent almost $600,000 on consulting, and advertising and promotional fees.
“Compounding matters was the lack of sufficient, complete and organized documentation to support a portion of the monies that were received and/or disbursed,” the report reads. “As a result, great reliance had to be placed on the integrity of the [OutGames] management to help explain these transactions' business purposes.”
The audit does appear to place some of the blame on the board.
“In addition, there was a lack of oversight from the Board of Directors as staging the World OutGames became the responsibility primarily of a handful of individuals who appeared to struggle with staging such a large event,” the report continues.
According to the OutGames program then current board members included: Bruce Townsend, Ivan Cano, Keith Hart, Jerry Torres, George Neary, and Nick Tierno. Past members included Steve Adkins, Bob Balsam (deceased), Cindy Brown, Karen Brown, Michael Góngora, Richard Murry and Jose Sotolongo.
The highest paid official was OutGames CEO Ivan Cano, who walked away with $106,992 in consulting fees. To put that into context, only $65,475 was spent on sporting events.
Before taking over the OutGames, Cano was executive director of Miami Beach Gay Pride. According to his Facebook page he’s since left the area and is now living in New Jersey. On June 15 he posted: “Spending quality time … on a healthier path. Today is a new day to build a better life.”
Immediately after the collapse of the event a criminal investigation was opened. Along with the audit last week, the Miami Herald reported it was announced that the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Office determined “there was no evidence found to proceed with a criminal prosecution.”
Regardless OutGames appeared to have attempted to deceive some hotels it worked with on its tax-exempt status. OutGames was not a 501c3 nonprofit, even though at one point they were attempting to become one.
In order to assist OutGames before they got their own tax exempt status, the Miami-Dade Gay and Lesbian Chamber of Commerce’s foundation agreed to act as their financial agent but only for the purposes of securing two grants.
Any other attempted use of the foundation’s tax exempt status was not appropriate said Adkins, President of the MDGLCC.
“Additionally, [OutGames] failed to properly qualify for the tax-exempt status they represented they maintained, thereby increasing its liabilities to The National Hotel and their booked participants,” reads a statement from National Hotel in Miami.
Adkins added: “World OutGames submitted our EIN number to one of the hotels in order to have the taxes waived. They did not have the authority to use our EIN to get a tax-exempt status.Whatever circumstances there were, they used it without our approval.”
The MDGLCC found this out when a hotel contacted them to confirm the arrangement.
“We were not pleased,” Adkins said.
As soon as the games were canceled Adkins said MDGLCC resigned as their fiscal agent.
When organizers canceled most of the events on opening day, it left athletes and locals infuriated. It’s still unclear though why they waited until the last minute. Many athletes were in route to Miami and had no idea until they landed that their events had been canceled.
Even more troubling is that some athletes paid for their hotel stays through OutGames, but organizers never paid the hotel, forcing athletes to pay for their stay again or find other arrangements.
“We are just the third party that didn't get fully paid by [OutGames]. The participants booked and paid a third party for their participation and accommodations and some of them for their meals,” said General Manager Yaser Mohamad. “As per our policies and signed registration cards, the guests are solely responsible for their charges in the event of non-payment. All guests should dispute their charges they paid World Out Games and not to dispute the charges for goods and services received from The National Hotel.”
After the cancellation announcement, most of the board immediately resigned.
Not everything was cancelled though. The human rights conference went on as scheduled despite the drama elsewhere. Lynare Robbins, the person in charge of that event, also resigned from her position but decided to stay on without pay to make sure the conference continued.
But to some behind the scenes organizers it was obvious to that the sporting events were not going to happen.
“We were ready to make it happen a week out,” said Frankie Ruiz, who produces local running and triathlon events. “It was going to be tough but we still felt we could make it happen.”
One week prior to the event Ruiz spoke with OutGames treasurer Keith Hart, who was supposed to call the next day to finalize details including payment. Ruiz never heard from anyone from OutGames again.
Ruiz said organizers initially hired him to plan a large-scale event that would have included 12 sports and cost upwards of $200,000. But as the event approached organizers continued to downsize.
“As the event got closer and closer, we got more nervous, there was no signed agreement, and they constantly asked us to revamp our proposal,” Ruiz said.
When organizers — including the board — walked away, Miami Beach city officials, Steve Adkins, and other locals stepped in to reschedule as many events as possible.
The 2020 World OutGames was slated to take place in Winnipeg, Canada. Last week the event was officially canceled.
"With the incident that happened in Miami this past June and how the athletes were treated, we feel that we are no longer in a position to deliver an exceptional experience for LGBTTQ* athletes under the OutGames banner," Jonathan Niemczak, chair of the 2020 planning committee, told CBCNews.
Top Paid People
Ivan Cano (Chief Executive Officer) – $106,992
Lynare Robbins (human rights conference) – $69,400
Carol Coombes (culture, arts and film) – $57,344
Marc Brown (former Sports Director) – $28,308
Jordan Selders (current Sports Director) – $25,894
P313, LLC (fund raising) - $24,000
Top Sponsorship Dollars
Adidas – $100,000
Blackpool Promotions – $49,965
My Gay Miami Sponsorship – $20,000
Happy Copenhagen – $19,944
Top Grant Dollars
City Of Miami Beach – $200,000
Miami Beach Visitor and Convention Authority (VCA) – $150,000
Miami-Dade County Tourism Development Council – $20,000